I recently purchased the MAC eye kohl in Smoulder and I have to say I was a little disappointed with it.
When I was younger I swore by kohl pencils to line my eyes. Eventually I moved on to liquid and gel liners but I bought this because I thought I would really love it but I really don't!!
I found that it smudged alot and although the black was intense at first eventually it wore of and smudged under my eyes giving me the dreaded bedroom-panda eyes.
This kohl is £11 and I have to say not worth the money! I've heard loads of people raving about how wonderful it is but I am going to have to differ. Maybe my hopes where to high and I'm disappointed but in the future I am sticking to my liquid and my gel liners!